State Lawmaker Demands Answers on Botched Tony Carruthers Execution Ahead of Darrell Hines Execution Date

Document Date: July 2, 2026

Lawmaker Demands Answers on Botched Tony Carruthers Execution Ahead of Darrell Hines Execution Date

Rep. Jody Barrett (R-69) is giving TDOC until July 20 to explain what went wrong before the state attempts another execution on August 13.

State Representative Jody Barrett (R-69) recently sent a letter to Tennessee Department of Correction Commissioner Frank Strada demanding answers about the botched execution attempt of Tony Carruthers. The state attempted to execute Mr. Carruthers in May despite the ACLU's continued push for DNA testing that could prove his innocence. The execution team spent more than an hour trying to establish an IV line while Mr. Carruthers groaned in pain before Governor Lee issued a one-year reprieve.

Barrett's letter raises the same questions ACLU has pressed since that day. In his July 1 letter, the State Representative gives Commissioner Strada until July 20 to explain what went wrong, what recent changes have been implemented, and why Tennesseans should trust the department to carry out the execution of Darrell Hines, scheduled for August 13. Barrett writes that "public confidence cannot exist without public accountability." Read the full letter here.

Related Content


Press Release
Read and black graphic with barb wire and a sign that says "NO TO DEATH PENALTY."

ACLU Demands DNA Testing That Could Prove Innocence of Tony Carruthers, Man on Tennessee Death Row

The state is preparing to execute Tony Carruthers on May 21 even though serious questions remain about whether they have the right person.
Press Release
Headshot of man with a long beard in sunglasses and a hat.
  • Criminal Legal Reform|
  • +1 Issue

Statement on Tennessee’s Torturous Execution Attempt of Tony Carruthers

ACLU comments on the state of Tennessee's botched and torturous attempt to execute Tony Carruthers